It is a never-ending debate. Electric Smoker or Charcoal Smoker which one to choose? Our one sentence answer is that ‘it depends on the user interest and requirement.’
Now, what if you are confused with what you are looking for? Chill guys, we are here to solve your questions and doubts related to making a selection between both the Smokers.
Electric Smoker or Charcoal Smoker
You will find a unique flavor in a Smoky food, which cannot be obtained in an oven or grilled type of cooking. This type of cooking is an old method, and it has been present for a long time. If you search out for types of smokers, then you will come across many varieties of them. All of them have got their unique purpose and usage method.
To highlight some of the difference between electric and charcoal smoker, Electric Smoker is easy to use compared to the other. Charcoal Smoker requires the user presence, while Electric one needs less user supervision. So if you are the kind of person who wishes to spend more time around the smoker with coals and wood chips, then you won’t like the electric smoker.
Now we would like to list some points to make the difference more clear. This will help in choosing the right Smoker system according to your need.
If you don’t have much space indoors, and looking for an outdoor smoker, then you consider both the Electric as well as the Charcoal Smoker in this case. Charcoal Smokers are only recommended for outdoor installation, so for those planning to install indoors then you can choose the Electric one only.
Also, it is must to have some space left around one Charcoal Smoker, to keep yourself safe from any fire cases. While there are some Electric Smokers which are installed outdoors; as they release some gas while processing. Therefore, choose the unit which matches your space availability.
Source of Fuel
This point can help you in choosing the unit which you wish to have. Talking about the Electric Smokers, they are fixed with the temperature provided in this. When we talk about the high-end electric units, they can go as high as 350°, whereas in a low-end unit you won’t get temperature more than 200°. This makes it a great option for those looking for an easy way of getting a consistent temperature.
While in Charcoal unit, the temperature ranges are found to be wide. But the challenge present here is with the building and maintenance of the desired temperature. So mastering the art is needed for the best results with the charcoal system.
If you want to go by the popularity of the smoker, then currently the Electric Smoker is getting popular. One of the main reasons for this is the dropping prices of this smoker, and ease of handling. You can get one basic electric smoker for about $100, and it can be installed in indoor as well as outdoor place.
Talking about the Charcoal unit, it has been for a long time now. This type of smoker is preferred more in the places which are famous for the barbecue food. It is popular in most of the places based in the United States.
Heating Process Preferred to You
Well, this point to the factor about the heating method preferred by you. When we are dealing with the Electric Smoker, here radiant waves are passed through the meat for some time, and then the unit is turned off. After some time, the coils are re-charged when any temperature drop is found in the unit. So here, major time of the food is cooked using indirect heat.
While in a charcoal unit, continuous heat is supplied till the fibers of the meat is broken down to give you the best flavored, juicy meat. So, depending on your preferred style of cooking you can choose from both Electric and Charcoal.
Size of the Smoker
Of course, Electric smokers need less space than Charcoal Smoker! The reason is, electric ones do not require space for keeping the coal containers which are present in the charcoal units. While you are dealing with charcoal smokers, you will find the large size, and also you have to provide some extra space for all the charcoal units. This is for safety issues.
But there is a relief for you here. You can easily choose from small to large sizes smokers for both the electric as well as charcoal smokers. Therefore, this choice may not help you much though.
Considering all the points listed above, it proves that Electric Smoker is preferable for all newbies. Whereas for all those looking to work with the woods and coals can easily opt for the Charcoal Smoker. Charcoal is recommended for best Smoky results.. So depending on your preferences and interests, you can opt for either one of them.
For updates, you can follow our page on Smokerify.